Why Every World Map Is Wrong: Map Projections Explained

Greenland is not the size of Africa, and no flat map can show the Earth perfectly. Learn how map projections work, why Mercator distorts, and which maps to use for what.

By Lavish Sethi · · 4 min read

Pull up almost any online map and zoom out. Greenland looks as large as Africa. Russia looks like it covers half the planet. Countries near the equator, like India, Brazil and the nations of central Africa, seem modest. None of this reflects reality, and it is not a mistake. It is a choice, and it is unavoidable that every flat map makes some choice like it.

Here is why every flat world map is "wrong" in some way, and how to pick the right one.

You cannot flatten a sphere without distortion

Try to flatten an orange peel on a table. It tears, stretches or wrinkles. The surface of the Earth behaves in the same way. In the nineteenth century the mathematician Carl Friedrich Gauss proved a result, sometimes called his Theorema Egregium, which implies that a curved surface like a sphere cannot be laid flat without distorting distances somewhere.

So every map projection, which is a mathematical method for turning the round Earth into a flat picture, must compromise. A projection can preserve some of these properties, but never all at once:

  • Shape (local angles look right)
  • Area (regions are shown at their true relative sizes)
  • Distance (scales are correct)
  • Direction (bearings are accurate)

The Mercator projection: great for sailors

The map most people picture is the Mercator projection, introduced by the Flemish cartographer Gerardus Mercator in 1569. It was designed for navigation. On a Mercator map, a line of constant compass bearing appears as a straight line, so a sailor could draw a line from port to port, read the angle, and steer by it.

To achieve this, Mercator's projection preserves local angles and shapes, which mapmakers call being conformal. The price is area. As you move away from the equator, the map stretches both east-west and north-south by increasing amounts. Near the poles the stretching becomes so extreme that the poles themselves cannot be shown at all; they would be infinitely far away.

Greenland versus Africa

The most famous illustration is Greenland. On a Mercator map it looks roughly the size of Africa. In reality:

Region Approximate area
Africa about 30.3 million km²
Greenland about 2.2 million km²
India about 3.3 million km²
Scandinavia (Norway, Sweden, Finland) about 1.2 million km²

Africa is roughly fourteen times larger than Greenland. India, which looks fairly compact on Mercator maps, is larger than Greenland and more than twice the size of Norway, Sweden and Finland combined, even though those countries can look comparable to India on a Mercator map.

A fun way to see this for yourself is to use an interactive tool such as The True Size Of, which lets you drag countries around a Mercator map and watch them shrink or grow as they move toward or away from the equator.

Why online maps still use Mercator

Popular web maps use a version called Web Mercator. That surprises people, but it makes sense for street-level use. Because Mercator preserves local shapes, streets meet at the right angles and buildings look correct when you zoom in on any city. When you are finding a café, local accuracy matters more than whether Greenland looks too big on a zoomed-out view. Some services now switch to a globe view when you zoom out far enough, which avoids the distortion entirely.

Equal-area maps: fair sizes, stretched shapes

If you care about comparing sizes, such as showing population density, forest cover or the area of countries, you need an equal-area projection. These keep every region at its correct relative size but distort shapes.

The Gall-Peters projection is the best-known example. It was first described by James Gall in the nineteenth century and promoted by Arno Peters in the 1970s as a fairer picture of the world, because it shows Africa and South America at their true size relative to Europe and North America. Critics point out that it badly stretches shapes, making continents near the equator look long and thin.

Other equal-area options, such as the Mollweide and equal Earth projections, give a more balanced look while still keeping areas correct.

Compromise projections: a bit of everything

Many atlases use projections that are neither perfectly conformal nor perfectly equal-area, but keep all distortions moderate. Two classic examples:

  • Robinson projection (1963): designed by Arthur Robinson to "look right." It was used by the National Geographic Society for its world maps for about a decade.
  • Winkel tripel projection: adopted by National Geographic in 1998, it minimises a combination of area, direction and distance distortion.

These are good choices for wall maps and general reference.

Seeing distortion with circles

Cartographers have a neat tool for showing distortion called Tissot's indicatrix. Imagine drawing identical small circles all over the globe and then projecting them. On a Mercator map, the circles stay circular but grow enormously toward the poles. On an equal-area map, they all keep the same area but get squashed into ellipses. A quick image search for "Tissot indicatrix" shows this beautifully for dozens of projections.

Which map should you use?

  • Navigation or street maps: Mercator or Web Mercator, for accurate local shapes and directions.
  • Comparing sizes or showing data by area: an equal-area projection such as Equal Earth or Mollweide.
  • A general wall map: a compromise projection like Winkel tripel or Robinson.
  • True picture of the whole planet: a globe. It is the only representation without distortion.

Key takeaways

  • A sphere cannot be flattened without distortion, so every flat map compromises.
  • Mercator preserves angles and shapes locally but greatly inflates areas far from the equator.
  • Africa is about fourteen times the size of Greenland, though Mercator maps make them look similar.
  • Equal-area projections show true sizes; compromise projections balance several distortions.

Further reading: USGS: Map projections; The True Size Of.