How Tariffs Work: Who Really Pays an Import Tax?

Tariffs are in the news constantly, but who actually pays them, and what do they do to prices, jobs and trade? A plain-English guide to how import taxes work.

By Lavish Sethi · · 5 min read

Few economic words appear in headlines as often as tariff. Governments announce them, raise them, cut them and threaten them as bargaining chips. Yet many people are unsure what a tariff actually is, who pays it, and why economists argue about them so much. This explainer covers the basics in a way that stays true no matter which country or year the headline is about.

What is a tariff?

A tariff is a tax on imported goods. When a product crosses a border into a country, that country's customs authority can charge a duty on it before it is allowed in. In India, for example, the main import tax is called Basic Customs Duty and is collected under the Customs Act; in the United States it is collected by Customs and Border Protection.

There are two main ways a tariff can be set:

  • Ad valorem tariffs are a percentage of the value of the goods. A 10 percent tariff on a ₹1,00,000 shipment adds ₹10,000.
  • Specific tariffs are a fixed amount per unit, such as a set charge per kilogram, litre or item.

Some tariffs combine both. Countries also use tariff-rate quotas, where a certain quantity can be imported at a low rate and anything above that faces a much higher rate.

Who pays the tariff?

This is the most misunderstood part. Legally, the tariff is paid by the importer, the business in the importing country that brings the goods in. It is not a bill sent to the foreign country or the foreign company.

What happens next depends on how the cost gets shared:

  1. The importer may absorb it, accepting lower profit margins.
  2. The importer may pass it on to shops and, eventually, consumers through higher prices.
  3. The foreign exporter may cut its price to stay competitive, effectively taking some of the hit.

Economists call this question tariff incidence. The answer varies case by case. However, careful studies of the large tariffs the United States imposed in 2018 and 2019 found that most of the cost was passed through to US importers and consumers rather than absorbed by foreign exporters. One well-known analysis is by Mary Amiti, Stephen Redding and David Weinstein, published in the Journal of Economic Perspectives in 2019.

So while a tariff is often described as "making the other country pay," the people in the importing country usually bear a large share.

Why do governments use tariffs?

If tariffs often raise prices at home, why use them? Governments give several reasons:

  • Protecting domestic industries. Making imports more expensive helps local producers compete, especially new or struggling industries. This is sometimes called the infant industry argument.
  • National security. Countries may want to keep domestic production of steel, medicines, semiconductors or defence equipment.
  • Raising revenue. Historically, tariffs were a major source of government income. For many countries today they are a smaller share of revenue than income tax or GST, but they still matter.
  • Bargaining power. A tariff, or the threat of one, can be used to pressure another country in trade negotiations.
  • Responding to unfair practices. Anti-dumping duties target goods sold abroad below fair value, and countervailing duties offset foreign subsidies.

The costs and side effects

Tariffs have trade-offs that are often discussed less loudly:

  • Higher prices for consumers. Imported goods, and sometimes the domestic goods competing with them, get more expensive.
  • Higher costs for businesses. Many tariffs hit inputs, such as steel, chemicals or components. A tariff that helps steelmakers can hurt car makers, construction firms and appliance makers that buy steel.
  • Retaliation. Trading partners often respond with tariffs of their own, frequently aimed at exporters in politically sensitive sectors like agriculture. That can hurt the very industries that depend on foreign markets.
  • Trade diversion. Rather than buying domestically, importers sometimes switch to a third country not covered by the tariff.
  • Less competition. Protected industries may face less pressure to innovate or keep prices down.

A famous historical example

The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 in the United States raised tariffs on thousands of imported goods. Other countries retaliated, and world trade fell sharply during the Great Depression. Economists still debate how much of the trade collapse was due to the tariffs rather than the depression itself, but Smoot-Hawley became a lasting symbol of the risks of a tariff war.

Tariffs and the World Trade Organization

Most countries are members of the World Trade Organization (WTO). WTO members agree to maximum tariff levels for different products, called bound rates. The tariffs they actually charge, called applied rates, are often lower.

A central WTO principle is most-favoured-nation treatment: a member should normally offer the same tariff to all other members rather than discriminating. Free trade agreements are an allowed exception, letting partners cut tariffs between themselves. There are also exceptions for national security, anti-dumping and safeguards against sudden import surges.

How to read a tariff headline

Next time you see a tariff in the news, ask these questions:

  1. What goods are covered? Finished consumer products, raw materials or components?
  2. How big is the rate, and is it on value or quantity?
  3. Who imports these goods, and can they easily switch suppliers?
  4. Is retaliation likely, and which industries would it target?
  5. Is it permanent, temporary, or a negotiating threat?

The answers usually tell you much more about the real effect than the headline number alone.

Key takeaways

  • A tariff is a tax on imports, collected by the importing country's customs authority.
  • The importer pays it legally; the cost is then shared among importers, consumers and sometimes foreign exporters.
  • Tariffs can protect industries and raise revenue, but often raise prices, invite retaliation and hurt businesses that rely on imported inputs.
  • WTO rules limit how members set tariffs, with exceptions for trade deals and specific trade remedies.

Further reading: WTO: Tariffs; Amiti, Redding and Weinstein (2019), The Impact of the 2018 Tariffs on Prices and Welfare, Journal of Economic Perspectives.